In this 2003 essay, David Bentley Hart explores what the consequence is for Western civilization “when Christianity, as a living historical force, recedes.” He argues that if it rejects Christ, the only remaining option for a post-Christian culture is conscious or “narcotic” nihilism, which takes the form of absolute, meaningless volition. This is the “god” of our age against which Christians must struggle in our adherence to the First Commandment. Because Christianity was victorious over the ancient world’s enchanting but ultimately tragic pagan gods and myths, there is no returning to them. That victory laid bare the nihilism behind those gods, bringing that dark power out into the open. But it also “baptized and redeemed” all the good treasures, wisdom, splendor of creation, and stirrings toward transcendence in the pagan religions, revealing them to be fulfilled in the God of Christianity. Hart concludes with a call for Christians to recover the wisdom of the ascetic tradition to keep the First Commandment and to counter the “bland solace, inane charms, brute viciousness, and dazed passivity of post-Christian culture.”
This essay is provided courtesy of First Things and is read by Ken Myers. It was first published in the October 2003 issue and may be found here.
A glossary of terms in the essay is provided below for your convenience and edification.
66 minutes
PREVIEW
The audio player for this program is restricted to MHA members and friends of FIRST THINGS. Log in or sign up now to listen to it.
Glossary
abyssal – referring to the abyss or the great deeps of the ocean
aqedah – (Hebrew) binding; refers to Abraham’s binding of his son Isaac on the altar
antinomian – relating to the view that Christians are released by grace from the obligation of observing the moral law
apophthegms – short, pithy, and instructive sayings
apotropaic – having the power to avert evil influences or bad luck
Attic tragedy – tragedy drama of ancient Greece
chorismos – (Greek) separation between the true, unchanging reality (Forms) and the phenomenal world of appearance
chthonian – concerning, belonging to, or inhabiting the underworld
dithyramb – a wild choral hymn of ancient Greece, especially one dedicated to Dionysus
ecpyrosis (or ekpyrosis) – (Greek) conflagration, or fiery destruction
eidetic – relating to or denoting mental images having unusual vividness and detail, as if actually visible
emollient – something that softens or smoothes
encomia – glowing and warmly enthusiastic praise
étagère – (French) a piece of furniture consisting of a set of open shelves for displaying small objects
gratia non perfecit, sed destruit naturam – (Latin) “Grace does not destroy nature, but perfects it”
inextirpable – something that is impossible to remove, destroy, or root out
qurban– (Arabic) a ritual sacrifice to draw near to God
manqué – (French) having failed to become what one might have been; unfulfilled
minatory – expressing or conveying a threat
peripety – a sudden and unexpected reversal of fortune or change in circumstances
précis – (French) a concise summary of essential points, statements, or facts
propria persona – (Latin) for one’s self, or in one’s own person
pusillanimity – lack of courage or determination; timidity
sepulture – burial; internment
spolia Aegyptiorum– (Latin) the practice of taking the “spoils” from the defeated party in war and putting them to new use
sublunary – belonging to this world, as contrasted with a better or more spiritual one
subordinationist – Christian heresy claiming that the Son and Holy Spirit are ontologically inferior or subordinate to the God the Father
ululations – long, high-pitched vocal sounds to express intense emotions; often used in religious or cultural ceremonies
When myth becomes fact — In this 1976 interview, Clyde Kilby (1902–1986) discusses C. S. Lewis’s critique of scientism and rationalism, his belief in the primacy of the imagination, and his mythic vision. (37 minutes)
“A Myth Retold” — Literary critic Thomas Howard explains why he considers C. S. Lewis’s Till We Have Faces to be one of the author’s richest and most rewarding works. (18 minutes)
Christian culture and the myth of the secular — Ken Myers draws on T. S. Eliot to argue that Western civilization has broken down, not into a multiplicity of cultures, but into a “post-culture.” (47 minutes)
The cost of “killing” God — In this October 2023 lecture, Carl Trueman explores the concept of “desecration” as a frame for understanding the nature of modernity in our time. (42 minutes)
A letter from Ken Myers — Ken Myers examines the cultural implications of the Incarnation and the deep-seated dualism of modernity that divorces spirituality from our material experience. (22 minutes)
Moral reasoning and human flourishing — Tim McIntosh describes moral philosopher Alasdair MacIntyre’s intellectual conversion to a synthesis of Aristotelian ethics and Christianity, best embodied in Thomism. (44 minutes)
Susanna Lee discusses moral authority in the heroes of hard-boiled crime fiction. (24 minutes)
The Heav’ns and All the Powers Therein — In this extended interview, Michael Ward makes a compelling case that the qualities attributed to the seven planets in the cosmology of antiquity and the Middle Ages are embodied in C. S. Lewis’s seven books about Narnia. (68 minutes)
Mordor versus the Shire — In this lecture, Heidi White explains how the modern project is a diabolical inversion of Christendom and calls for Christians to build lives and a culture that can counter it. (53 minutes)
Christian Smith discusses the aimless cultural world of emerging adulthood and on how it makes the idea of objective moral order implausible. (17 minutes)
University or “utiliversity”? — In this essay, Reinhard Hütter examines in depth John Henry Newman’s The Idea of a University and argues that its insights and prescriptions are urgently relevant to the current status of higher education. (87 minutes)
Media as agencies of order — Media theorist John Durham Peters wants us to reexamine the purposes of media and how fundamental media are. (59 minutes)
Roger Lundin discusses the ethical and theological consequences of our postmodern culture. (9 minutes)
The demoralizing effect of pagan Roman religion — Oliver O’Donovan examines St. Augustine’s critique of pagan Roman religion in Book II of his treatise City of God and asks his audience to consider what insights Augustine’s critique has for us today. (Lecture 1 of 3; 51 minutes)
R. J. Snell discusses how novel ideas about natural law focus less on moral propositions and concepts and more on the thrust for meaning and value. (27 minutes)
Robert Richardson and Roger Lundin discuss how Ralph Waldo Emerson’s legacy lingers in American culture. (18 minutes)
Seneca’s moral courage — Dana Gioia explains how Seneca’s family was interwoven with the Roman governing class, ultimately leading to the philospher’s death at the hands of Emperor Nero. (27 minutes)
Dana Gioia discusses the important role literary reading plays in society and the 2004 publication from the NEA about such reading. (13 minutes)
From culture war to culture care — In this 2016 lecture, artist Makoto Fujimura asks what would it look like for Christians to be stewards of beauty and human flourishing in all areas of life and culture. (48 minutes)
Matthew Levering talks about the long and rich tradition of reasoning about God. (23 minutes)
Etiquette and ethics — In this essay, Judith Martin (a.k.a. Miss Manners) argues that etiquette is “civilization’s first necessity” and an indispensable societal virtue. (21 minutes)
Professor Christopher Shannon discusses how early twentieth-century social scientists encouraged the American idea that individual identity works against communal membership. (17 minutes)
Mars Hill Audio Journal, Volume 163 — FEATURED GUESTS: Andrew Youngblood, R. J. Snell, Nicholas Denysenko, Nigel Biggar, Robert McNamara, and David Cayley
An “austerely chastened” pneumatology — In this lecture, Ephraim Radner critiques modern pneumatology for effectually denying the “difficult givenness” of this life and implicitly subverting our human creatureliness. (40 minutes)
Michael J. Lewis explores the effects of the Body Worlds exhibits on the moral imagination of the viewer, who encounters human cadavers in a mechanistic way erased of all moral context. (26 minutes)
Donald McCullough discusses his insights into the increasingly coarse nature of society and the theological foundations for courtesy. (12 minutes)
Is American culture now story-less? — From our archives, Michael Kammen compares popular and mass culture, and Philip Fisher analyzes the idea that new cultural forms inevitably dissolve old ones. (26 minutes)
William C. Hackett discusses the relationships between philosophy and theology, and of both to the meaning embedded in myth. (29 minutes)
Christopher Hitchens vs. G. K. Chesterton — Ralph Wood compares Christopher Hitchens‘s view of the cosmos with that of G. K. Chesterton, arguing that Chesterton succeeded where Hitchens failed. (44 minutes)
A fearful darkness in mind, heart, and spirit — Roberta Bayer draws on the work of George Parkin Grant (1918–1988) to argue that our “culture of death” must be countered with an understanding of reality based in love, redemptive suffering, and a recognition of limitations to individual control. (33 minutes)
This Archive Feature revisits two conversations, one with Roger Lundin and one with David Bentley Hart, on what makes Christian belief so implausible to non-believers. (39 minutes)
Eric Miller discusses the late historian and social critic Christopher Lasch’s intense commitment to understand the logic of American cultural confusion. (20 minutes)
Thomas Hibbs, author of Shows about Nothing, discusses the nihilism that runs through films and television shows in recent American popular culture. (9 minutes)
David Bentley Hart describes how the Christian understanding of Creation as beauty and gift, as the outward expression of the delight the Trinity has in itself, reveals a vision of reality different from the pagan or fatalist vision of reality. (12 minutes)
Ralph C. Wood describes G. K. Chesterton’s imagination as especially fruitful in conveying grace and edification to his readers. (19 minutes)
Mechanism and the abolition of meaning — On the occasion of philosopher Daniel Dennett’s death this week, Ken Myers presents an archive interview with David Bentley Hart in which he explains how pure naturalism leads to the un-doing of rationality. (37 minutes)